Columbia SC Counselor Guide
Menu

Mental Health & Anxiety Counseling in Cayce

Mental Health & Anxiety Counseling in Columbia

Mental health and anxiety counseling covers the talk-therapy work most people picture when they think of seeing a counselor: regular sessions with a licensed therapist to work through anxiety, panic, depression, stress, trauma, grief, or general life overwhelm. Sessions usually run 45-60 minutes and involve a mix of listening, structured techniques (like cognitive behavioral therapy or exposure work for anxiety), and homework or coping strategies to practice between visits. Cayce has 33 counseling practices offering this kind of care, ranging from solo therapists to group practices with multiple clinicians.

Because so much of this work depends on personal fit, the right choice isn't always the biggest or the busiest practice. A few things worth checking before you book a first session:

  • Licensure and specialty: look for a licensed professional counselor (LPC), clinical social worker (LCSW), or psychologist with actual experience treating anxiety, not just general counseling.
  • Approach: some therapists lean heavily on CBT or exposure therapy for anxiety, others take a more open-ended talk-therapy approach. Ask what they'd actually do in a session.
  • Logistics: insurance acceptance, sliding-scale fees, telehealth options, and how quickly they can get you in matter as much as credentials, especially if you're dealing with an active crisis.
  • Communication style: a good fit often comes down to whether you feel heard in the first session or two.

Our scoring weighs credentials, client feedback, responsiveness, and consistency over time rather than just star averages, so you can compare practices on more than marketing. See the full breakdown of how we score providers on the methodology page, or jump straight to the ranked list of Cayce counselors to see how these 33 practices stack up.

Get quotes from suitable mental health & anxiety counseling in Cayce

Free, no obligation. Tell us what you're looking for and we'll connect you with suitable counselors.

Compare quotes

All mental health & anxiety counseling in Cayce, ranked by score and relevance

We found 33 businesses offering mental health & anxiety counseling in Cayce; 26 met the criteria for the scored directory. The order weighs each business's overall score by how much of its reviewed work is mental health & anxiety counseling, so a lower-scored specialist can rank above a higher-scored generalist.

Maihan Yazmine Aurah, Psychiatric Nurse Practitioner
#1
83

Maihan Yazmine Aurah, Psychiatric Nurse Practitioner

4.8(47)✓ Google-verified

Patients consistently describe Maihan Aurah as a deeply engaged clinician who listens without judgment and remembers details. Her willingness to adjust medications when prior approaches failed, combined with genuine care for each person's life circumstances, sets her apart from transactional providers. Her knowledge of mood disorders and medication management is paired with referrals to therapy when helpful. Zoom appointments are available and easy to book. One patient reported difficulty with the website portal, though her clinical care itself drew praise even in that review.

Mental Health & Anxiety Counseling
LifeStance Therapists & Psychiatrists Cayce
#2
87

LifeStance Therapists & Psychiatrists Cayce

4.6(227)✓ Google-verified

Staff here know how to listen. Reviewers repeatedly name therapists by name (Kya Davis, Dr. Lynn Gilderhus, Karen Smith, Heather) and describe feeling truly heard and supported through difficult conversations. Booking is straightforward, and medication management is praised for correcting long-standing issues.

Mental Health & Anxiety CounselingChild & Adolescent CounselingSubstance Abuse & Addiction Counseling
Kya Coreisa Davis, Psychiatric Nurse Practitioner
#3
78

Kya Coreisa Davis, Psychiatric Nurse Practitioner

4.7(29)✓ Google-verified

Most patients describe Kya Davis as attentive and informed, making them feel heard and supported during their sessions. She moves quickly through appointments without dragging them out, and many credit her medical knowledge and caring approach to psychiatric medication management. A small number raise concerns: one front desk interaction was reportedly disrespectful, and another patient objected to being offered multiple medications when their existing regimen was working. The overall pattern suggests strong clinical rapport but occasional lapses in office management and prescribing philosophy.

Mental Health & Anxiety CounselingChild & Adolescent CounselingSubstance Abuse & Addiction Counseling
Duncan Howe, Counselor
#4
79

Duncan Howe, Counselor

4.7(23)✓ Google-verified

Reviewers consistently describe Duncan as a skilled, attentive listener who creates a calm space to open up. Most report quick scheduling and practical takeaways like mindfulness techniques. One concern: initial front desk interactions can feel cold, though Duncan himself offsets this with warmth. His practice spans anxiety, trauma, PTSD, and panic attacks. Staff are noted as professional. He coordinates referrals to psychiatrists when needed. The therapist-client fit appears strong across reviews spanning over a year.

Mental Health & Anxiety CounselingChild & Adolescent CounselingCareer & Life Coaching
Michelle Whitlow-Blanding, Counselor
#5
79

Michelle Whitlow-Blanding, Counselor

5.0(10)✓ Google-verified

People consistently describe Michelle as warm, attentive, and genuinely committed to their healing. Sessions feel safe and productive, with flexible scheduling that respects individual needs.

Mental Health & Anxiety CounselingChild & Adolescent CounselingCareer & Life Coaching

Get quotes from suitable mental health & anxiety counseling in Cayce

Free, no obligation. Tell us what you're looking for and we'll connect you with suitable counselors.

Compare quotes
Nancy Winston, Counselor
#6
77

Nancy Winston, Counselor

5.0(13)✓ Google-verified

Nancy Winston builds comfort and connection quickly, listening carefully and helping clients set achievable goals without rushing through sessions. She offers individual, couples, and family therapy in person or by phone, though some find the no-show fees steep and the Summerville office hard to reach by phone.

Mental Health & Anxiety CounselingChild & Adolescent CounselingCareer & Life Coaching
Debbie Maxwell, Counselor
#7
76

Debbie Maxwell, Counselor

4.8(13)✓ Google-verified

Debbie Maxwell earns strong marks for being approachable and practical. Most reviewers praise her knowledge, techniques they can use between sessions, and her compassion when handling anxiety, grief, and trauma. One reviewer noted she can push too hard too fast with new trauma clients without first understanding what works for that individual, leading to resistance rather than progress.

Mental Health & Anxiety CounselingChild & Adolescent CounselingGrief & Trauma Counseling
Karen M Smith, Counselor
#8
70 low data

Karen M Smith, Counselor

5.0(6)✓ Google-verified

Karen Smith earns consistent praise for her calm manner and real-world advice grounded in experience rather than textbook solutions. Clients report meaningful breakthroughs with grief, relationships, and life stress. Review evidence is limited to six responses, all five-star, so depth on specific outcomes and limitations is sparse.

Mental Health & Anxiety CounselingGrief & Trauma CounselingCareer & Life Coaching
Erica Whitaker, Counselor
#9
70 low data

Erica Whitaker, Counselor

5.0(4)✓ Google-verified

Reviewers consistently describe Erica Whitaker as caring, genuine, and skilled at making new clients feel instantly comfortable. Sessions leave people feeling better, with strong rapport evident even at the first appointment.

Mental Health & Anxiety CounselingChild & Adolescent CounselingCareer & Life Coaching
Jenkins Simply Said Counseling Service, LLC
#10
69 low data

Jenkins Simply Said Counseling Service, LLC

5.0(19)✓ Google-verifiedPublishes prices

LaRaine Jenkins earns universal five-star ratings over years. Clients describe feeling heard, safe, and supported through major life changes. Her straightforward style, sense of humor, and genuine care help people-especially anxious introverts and children-open up and make progress.

Mental Health & Anxiety CounselingChild & Adolescent CounselingGrief & Trauma Counseling
Valentine Baptiste-Thomas, Counselor
#11
68 low data

Valentine Baptiste-Thomas, Counselor

4.8(4)✓ Google-verified

Valentine Baptiste-Thomas builds strong rapport with clients and delivers solid counseling experiences. One scheduling hiccup noted, but overall reception is warm and supportive.

Mental Health & Anxiety CounselingChild & Adolescent CounselingCareer & Life Coaching
Robert Karpe, Counselor
#12
68 low data

Robert Karpe, Counselor

5.0(3)✓ Google-verified

Robert Karpe brings a relaxed, caring style to therapy. Reviewers consistently mention his patience, humor, and ability to make them feel comfortable discussing difficult topics while prompting genuine reflection.

Mental Health & Anxiety CounselingChild & Adolescent CounselingGrief & Trauma Counseling
LaToya Edwards, Counselor
#13
67 low data

LaToya Edwards, Counselor

5.0(9)✓ Google-verified

One reviewer described her year of therapy as life-changing and credited LaToya Edwards with addressing multiple areas of her life. Another noted a friendly, welcoming office inside the Bank of America building, though location signage could be clearer.

Mental Health & Anxiety CounselingChild & Adolescent CounselingCareer & Life Coaching
Maggie Malaney, Counselor
#14
65 low data

Maggie Malaney, Counselor

5.0(3)✓ Google-verified

Reviewer found Maggie Malaney clear and approachable, delivering mental health support that inspired trust and confidence.

Mental Health & Anxiety CounselingChild & Adolescent CounselingGrief & Trauma Counseling
Tasha Cowan, Counselor
#15
65 low data

Tasha Cowan, Counselor

5.0(1)✓ Google-verified

One reviewer found scheduling straightforward. Limited review data, so this profile reflects only that single five-star report.

Mental Health & Anxiety CounselingChild & Adolescent CounselingCareer & Life Coaching
Heather Gates, Counselor
#16
65 low data

Heather Gates, Counselor

5.0(2)✓ Google-verified

Heather Gates is praised for creating a welcoming, judgment-free environment where both adults and children feel heard and safe. Review evidence is limited (based on 2 five-star ratings), but mentions her professional approach and range across individual and family work.

Mental Health & Anxiety CounselingChild & Adolescent CounselingGrief & Trauma Counseling
Michelle Benson, Counselor
#17
64 low data

Michelle Benson, Counselor

5.0(3)✓ Google-verified

Limited review evidence, but sessions with Michelle Benson are marked by calm surroundings and a therapist who listens carefully and teaches concrete skills for managing emotions and day-to-day stress.

Mental Health & Anxiety CounselingChild & Adolescent CounselingCareer & Life Coaching
Trent Peeler, Counselor
#18
61 low data

Trent Peeler, Counselor

3.0(2)✓ Google-verified

One recent client found Trent deeply understanding and left sessions with renewed hope. Another stopped after finding the approach unhelpful. With only two reviews, the picture is incomplete.

Mental Health & Anxiety CounselingChild & Adolescent Counseling
Lynn Gilderhus, Counselor
#19
57 low data

Lynn Gilderhus, Counselor

5.0(5)✓ Google-verified

Perfect five-star rating across five Google reviews suggests strong client satisfaction, though limited review detail prevents deeper insight into specific strengths or concerns.

Mental Health & Anxiety CounselingGrief & Trauma CounselingCareer & Life Coaching
Saquia McNeil, Counselor
#20
52 low data

Saquia McNeil, Counselor

5.0(1)✓ Google-verified

One five-star review supports this practice, though detailed evidence is limited. Their website lists individual, family, and couples therapy plus ADHD, anxiety, trauma, depression, and LGBTQ+ support.

Mental Health & Anxiety CounselingChild & Adolescent Counseling
Cayce Counseling Services, LLC
#21
45 low data

Cayce Counseling Services, LLC

5.0(1)✓ Google-verified

Not enough recent reviews yet to synthesise a reliable sentiment read for this business.

Mental Health & Anxiety CounselingChild & Adolescent CounselingSubstance Abuse & Addiction Counseling
Carlett Jethroe, Psychiatric Nurse Practitioner
#22
29 low data

Carlett Jethroe, Psychiatric Nurse Practitioner

No rating yet✓ Google-verified

Limited review evidence is available for this business. Carlett Jethroe holds PMHNP certification and lists psychiatric medication management, therapy for adults and children, couples and family services, autism evaluation, and online appointments on their website.

Mental Health & Anxiety CounselingSubstance Abuse & Addiction Counseling
Paula Dyer, Psychiatric Nurse Practitioner
#23
29 low data

Paula Dyer, Psychiatric Nurse Practitioner

No rating yet✓ Google-verified

Review evidence is limited. Paula Dyer is a board-certified psychiatric nurse practitioner offering medication management and therapy in Cayce through in-office and online visits.

Mental Health & Anxiety CounselingChild & Adolescent CounselingSubstance Abuse & Addiction Counseling
Rachel Brewster, Counselor
#24
29 low data

Rachel Brewster, Counselor

No rating yet✓ Google-verified

Review evidence is limited. The business states it provides individual and family therapy, ADHD and anxiety treatment, and trauma support. Rachel Brewster holds an LPC credential and operates 7 days a week in Cayce.

Mental Health & Anxiety CounselingChild & Adolescent CounselingCareer & Life Coaching
Laketa Riley, Psychiatric Nurse Practitioner
#25
27 low data

Laketa Riley, Psychiatric Nurse Practitioner

No rating yet✓ Google-verified

Not enough recent reviews yet to synthesise a reliable sentiment read for this business.

Mental Health & Anxiety CounselingChild & Adolescent CounselingSubstance Abuse & Addiction Counseling
Racquel Sims, Counselor
#26
27 low data

Racquel Sims, Counselor

No rating yet✓ Google-verified

Not enough recent reviews yet to synthesise a reliable sentiment read for this business.

Mental Health & Anxiety CounselingChild & Adolescent CounselingCareer & Life Coaching

Get quotes from our featured partners

How many quotes would you like?

You agree that when you send this enquiry we share it with providers relevant to your request.

Enquiries from this site's forms may be passed to partner providers who can do the work, and we may earn a referral fee. Our rankings and scores follow our published method only and are not affected by referral fees.

Common questions about mental health & anxiety counseling

How much does anxiety counseling cost in Cayce?
Rates typically run $80-$200 per session depending on the clinician's licensure level and whether they're in-network with your insurance. Many practices offer sliding-scale fees for self-pay clients, and some offer reduced rates for students or a first consultation at a lower cost.
How often do I need to go to counseling for anxiety?
Weekly sessions are standard for the first couple of months, especially with CBT-based approaches that build on skills from week to week. Many people space sessions out to biweekly or monthly once symptoms are more manageable, and some use counseling short-term for a specific stressor rather than ongoing care.
What should I expect in a first counseling session?
The first session is usually an intake: the therapist asks about your history, current symptoms, and what you're hoping to get out of counseling. It's less about diving into deep work and more about the therapist understanding your situation and both of you deciding if it's a good fit.
How do I know if a counselor is actually good?
Look past star ratings alone. Check whether they specialize in anxiety specifically, how they describe their approach, whether they respond promptly to inquiries, and whether client feedback mentions feeling genuinely helped rather than just generic praise. Consistency in reviews over time is a stronger signal than a handful of five-star ratings.

Last updated 2026-08-17